On a visit to the US last year, I came across a product called Forever Black which is used, as the name implies, to restore the black to a car's plastic, vinyl, or rubber surfaces. There are two unique things about it. First is that its permanent, unlike other products which last a few days to a few weeks at most; and the second is that it is a dye rather than a paint. Being a dye, the consistency is much thinner than paint and application is the same as using liquid shoe polish. In fact, it comes in a container very much like liquid shoe polish. The thin consistency preserves whatever surface finish is present despite repeated applications. Its a little bit pricey but I have seen its effectiveness when I used it to restore the black bumper trim on Winny. After 6 months and counting, the dyed rubber still looks good as new. This is how the shifter cover turned out:
In the end, I decided to do it myself. The risk-taker in me thought that I had little to lose since if it did not turn out to my satisfaction, I could just re-dye the whole thing and then move on to the next possibility. I bought a white permanent paint pen (a dangerous weapon in somebody with shaky hands) and just gave it a go. As expected the first coating was very uneven but after another few coats, the letters were starting to look good. Gaining confidence, I continued to outline the borders as close as possible to their edge and it helped that the letters were actually raised from the surface. However, there is no way to overcome an unsteady right hand so an increasing number spillovers came up and ruined the effect. I was about to give up when it hit me to try scraping off the excess. Because there was a thicker layer of paint in the intended areas, I thought that if I could somehow find a way to cut off whatever should not be there, then problem solved. A small tool with a sharp edge should do the trick and for this my miniature screwdriver for eyeglasses was perfect. Using gentle pressure, I was able to outline what needed to be removed and the task was made easier as the paint and dye did not bond together as closely as would have paint with paint. Unveiling the result to the world: